Quality Issues Versus Mechanical Errors

Is the quality of writing the most important thing for any book?  I’ve touched on this subject before, but I think it worth revisiting.  There has been considerable chatter on the subject, on blogs and Facebook.  There seems to be moves to push for better grammar and spelling, which might seem fair enough.  I have read books where the quality of the writing most definitely left much to be desired.  In reality, however, I’ve often found that a story is so intriguing, or a concept behind a story so worthwhile, that I’ve not only persevered in reading to the end, I actually read some of the books time and again.

I don’t claim to be perfect in my own writing.  I’m pretty much self-taught, as in most things I’ve ever done.  I could, of course, take courses to improve my writing quality, but would it really help to bring stories to light?  I have this terrible suspicion that I would spend so much time worrying about maintaining the proper quality that I would actually never complete anything.  Worse, the pleasure I derive from writing would be lost, forever.  Is it worth it?  Am I better off simply doing what I’ve always done?  I suspect the answers to these questions are “no” and “yes” respectively.

Having reached this conclusion, what right have I to judge and condemn other authors for their failings?  Of course I would prefer it if everything I read was easy to read.  Being comfortable is part of the pleasure of reading.  Despite that, I’m finding myself less concerned with quality than with ideas, though poor spelling still tends to aggravate me.  In truth, I find typographical errors and editorial mistakes far more annoying, together with gross mistakes in “facts”.  I have been content to accept poor quality writing only to be utterly infuriated when a continuity error in the manuscript occurs, whereby a paragraph is somehow confused with text from later or earlier in the tale.  Also, I’m finding occasions in ebooks where the editing can only be described as abysmal!  Punctuation is missing, replaced with incorrect characters (such as “ being somehow translated to /), and the flow of the story is very effectively sabotaged.  Page breaks appear in strange places, even in the midst of words.  These things, the mechanics of printing, if you like, are doing more to make books unpleasant to read than any difficulty with quality.

I have no desire to become a snob about the things I read.  I am not a book critic!  If I review a book, I do so based purely on the merits of the story.  I have no interest in anything beyond that.  Some things are, after all, beyond the control of the author, however much proofreading they may become embroiled in.  Receiving the galley proofs, making the appropriate corrections, and returning them promptly clearly has little influence on the final product.  There’s obviously something breaking down between publisher and printer.  When ebooks suffer similar problems, then I can only assume that either they are simply direct copies of the printed version (complete with errors) or the product of third party involvement intruding between author and final copy.

If we have so little control over the problems caused by others involved in the publishing process, I think that we really need to reconsider our attitude towards any failings of the author.  Let’s stop bullying writers, lecturing them on their errors.  If anybody is deserving of criticism, it is the people who can cause such atrocious disruption to the finished product.  If you must complain, complain to the ones who are responsible for the mechanical errors.

~ Steve

This entry was posted in Author, general, Steve K Smy and tagged , , , , , , , , , by Steve. Bookmark the permalink.

About Steve

An author since the age of 13 years, writing again dominates my activities. My "Imagineer-ing" blog is my primary site. Also: Beginner knitter since November 2010. Favourite knitting techniques: cable and lace. Beginner cross stitcher. Beginner jewellery maker. With the promotion of self publication and all the other work that has been going on here, Dad decided around 2am this morning (22/11/2013) that it was time to begin his next adventure. He was seen off earlier the previous evening by myself, my brother, my sister in law, and my sister, as well as his wife (our mum), and an enigmatic being known only as A Lorraine. After this time of story telling, laughing, crying, joking and mickey taking, we saw how tired both mum and dad were, and we decided to leave them under the (sometimes) gentle care of The Lorraine. When Dad found the timetable for his travels, he let Mum know gently, which woke her from her drowsing, then, with the same gentleness he showed in this universe, he boarded his favourite mode of transport, the Interdimensional Steam Train, and set off with a smile and a wave. For those of us closest, that smile was a reminder that his pain has ended, and the wave, an indicator that he will pop in to all those that knew him, from time to time. Usually at the most inconvenient and in opportune moments he can. While we are sad that he is no longer here, we are happy he now has no pain, and is experiencing more extraordinary things that his writers mind will be frantically weaving into a new story. Posted by Son Damien

2 thoughts on “Quality Issues Versus Mechanical Errors

  1. An interesting take on the subject. I didn’t pay for my collection of short stories, The First Time to be edited, however I will, almost certainly use the services of an editor and/or proof reader for Samantha (the story on which I am currently working).

    • Thanks for the comment 🙂 I appreciate your own view – I guess I’m just trying to sound a cautionary note, warning that even professional editors and proofreaders can make some major blunders 😉

Please leave your comment(s)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s